What makes a mascara not just good, but the best? Is it the formula? Or the brush? Obviously the best mascara has to be non-clumping and smudge-proof. But what is more important, volume or length? And do the best mascaras make your eyelashes look natural or dramatic?

There are many criteria mascaras must fulfill in order to be considered the best and there are a seemingly infinite number of mascaras on the market, so it can be kind of overwhelming trying to find the perfect one for your eyelash needs. Luckily, our Supergreat community has reviewed dozens, maybe even hundreds, of mascaras and we’ve compiled a list of the top 20 on the app to help you wade through the black sea of volumizing and lengthening formulas.

1. Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara

Things that are better than sex: chocolate, rewards, jeans that fit your waist AND your thighs, and Too Faced’s Better Than Sex Mascara. Our community loves the hourglass-shaped wand that mimics the curves of a woman’s body and adds voluptuous volume to every lash. This $25 buildable black mascara promises to be smudge-proof for all-day wear. Add one coat for full and defined lashes or three coats for your most dramatic lashes ever.

Watch more Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara reviews

2. Glossier Lash Slick

Glossier calls this mascara “extensions without the extensions.” The Lash Slick formula contains very small fibers to add length to lashes without extreme volume or clumping so lashes look natural and feathery. Keeping with Glossier’s no-makeup makeup look, this is the perfect $16 mascara to wear every day. It's also water-resistant but not waterproof so it is smudge-proof but still easy to take off at the end of the day.

Watch more Glossier Lash Slick reviews

3. Pacifica Highest Lash Chronic Volume Mascara

Get high…lashes, that is, with Pacifica’s Highest Lash Chronic Volume Mascara. The formula is infused with hemp-derived cannabis sativa oil for ultra-black drama and hemp fibers for extra length and lift. Even the vegan bristle brush has a twist (literally) to help separate lashes and add volume. If you want lashes that reach for the sky, this $14 mascara will give them a boost.

Watch more Pacifica Highest Lash Chronic Volume Mascara reviews

4. Milk Makeup Kush High Volume Mascara

We have a strong cannabis theme going on right now. Take a hit of Milk Makeup’s Kush High Volume Mascara. The plant-derived oil in this $24 mascara fuses heart-shaped fibers to each lash. What are heart-shaped fibers, you ask? We can only assume that means the fibers are curled like half of a heart to add extra volume, length, and curl to each lash. That also means this the perfect mascara if you have stick-straight lashes.

Watch more Milk Makeup Kush High Volume Mascara reviews

5. L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara

We're all dreaming of a vacation right now (or just normal life would be fine), so throw on a few coats of L’Oreal’s Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara. The 200+ bristles on the brush will fan out and coat your lashes until your lashes are like mini visors over your eyes, protecting them from the sun. Many of our Supergreater’s who love this $11 mascara say it is a dupe of Too Faced’s Better Than Sex Mascara. Can someone do a side-by-side test to confirm?

Watch more L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara reviews

6. Maybelline Lash Sensational Volumizing Mascara

No matter your lash type (straight, blonde, short, unruly, etc.) make them sensational with Maybelline’s Lash Sensational Volumizing Mascara. The spoolie brush on this $10 mascara contains ten layers of bristles (that’s a dollar per layer!) to fan out lashes and give them a 360-degree coat of this blackest black formula. The brush is also curved slightly to add even more space between lashes so they look full and feathery.

Watch more Maybelline Lash Sensational Volumizing Mascara reviews

7. Maybelline Snapscara Mascara in Pitch Black

The color is important to note here because Maybelline’s Snapscara Mascara also comes in some unique shades like Ultra Violet, Black Cherry, and Deja Blue, but our Supergreat community still prefers the classic black lash look. Color isn’t the only thing that makes this $8 mascara different. It's Maybelline’s first wax-free mascara so it's a snap to remove at the end of the day. Just splash with warm water and gently massage. No need for tugging or makeup remover!

Watch more Maybelline Snapscara Mascara in Pitch Black reviews

8. Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Mascara

Have you ever wished there was a mini curling iron that would curl your lashes? Well, that doesn’t exist for obvious eye-burning reasons, but Benefit Cosmetics’ Roller Lash Mascara is the next best thing. The hook ‘n roll brush grabs, separates, lifts, and curls all in one stroke, while the curve setting formula holds lashes for up to 12 hours. This $25 mascara also contains lash conditioning ingredients provitamin B5 and serin for soft, healthy lashes.

Watch more Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Mascara reviews

9. Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Natural Mascara

Tarte calls this mascara “a pushup bra for your lashes” and our Supergreaters can definitely see why. This $23 mascara provides lift and volume so lashes look perkier and bigger than they really are. Lights, Camera, Lashes is also formulated with lash softening and nourishing ingredients like olive esters, rice bran wax, and provitamin B5 to help enhance the appearance of your natural lash.

Watch more Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Natural Mascara reviews

10. Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG Mascara

Don’t get it confused—BADgal Mascara is not the name of Rihanna’s new Fenty Beauty mascara, even if her Instagram handle is @badgalriri. This is Benefit Cosmetics bigger, badder volumizing mascara designed to last up to 36 hours, because sometimes bad girls don’t wash their face at the end of the night (that’s how you know they’re bad). The Slimpact! brush is made with short bristles, making it easier for you to coat your lashes from root to tip so you can go out with bangin’ eyelashes.

Watch more Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG Mascara reviews

11. Queendom Unlashed Mascara

If the queen of England asked us for a mascara recommendation, we might suggest Queendom’s Unlashed Mascara. Like Milk Makeup’s Kush Mascara, this $18 tube contains heart shaped fibers to add length and curl to every lash. Plus, the wand contains a different bristle density halfway around so you can choose how together or separated you want your lashes to be. Apply this mascara whenever you want to “unlash” your inner queen and rule the world.

Watch more Queendom Unlashed Mascara reviews

12. Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara

This is exactly the same as the mascara that won first place, the only difference is that it’s the waterproof version. Our guess is that our community prefers washability over cry-proof and sweat-proof formulas. We can’t blame them, tugging and pulling on your lashes to remove waterproof mascara is tiring, but sometimes a waterproof mascara is necessary, like when it’s raining or snowing or you want to emphasize your lashes by the pool.

Watch more Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara reviews

13. Thrive Causmetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara

Your lashes will thrive wearing Thrive Causemetic’s Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara. This $24 mascara comes in two shades: black and brown black. It’s also infused with Thrive’s Orchid Stem Cell Complex, a mix of vitamin B5 and sodium hyaluronate, to moisturize and strengthen lashes. Our community especially loves how easy this mascara is to remove. They say just water does the trick!

Watch more Thrive Cosmetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara reviews

14. It Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara

Not all heroes wear capes. Some come in slim black tubes with dense black wands. It Cosmetics’ Superhero Elastic Stretch Mascara saves lashes with just a few swipes. This $25 black cape formula is infused with lash-lifting polymers, volumizing collagen, strengthening biotin, proteins and peptides for long, healthy lashes.

Watch more It Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara reviews

15. Too Faced Damn Girl Mascara

This mascara won’t weigh your lashes down. Too Faced’s Damn Girl Mascara is a creamy mouse formula with a whipped consistency that delivers length and curl without making lashes feel heavy. This $25 mascara promises to last up to 24 hours without smudging or flaking. It will make your lashes look so good you friends will ask, “Damn Girl! Are your lashes real?”

Watch more Too Faced Damn Girl Mascara reviews

16. Lancôme Monsieur Big Volume Mascara

Say "au revoir!" to falsies and lash extensions. Lancôme’s Monsieur Big Volume Mascara contains black boosting polymer in its pigment to provide 12x more volume and up to 24 hours of wear. Also, the wand on this $25 mascara includes wavy fibers to encapsulate the formula and deliver an even coat on every lash.

Watch more Lancôme Monsieur Big Volume Mascara reviews

17. Tarte Big Ego Mascara

Sometimes having a big ego is a good thing, especially when it comes to your lashes. Tarte’s Big Ego Vegan Mascara creates full, flake-free lashes. This $23 formula is made from babassu to nourish lashes, glycerin for hydration, vitamin B5 to soothe and hydrate, and sunflower seed wax to thicken.

Watch more Tarte Big Ego Mascara reviews

18. L’Oreal Paris Telescopic Mascara

Adding one coat of L’Oreal Paris’ Telescopic Mascara will make them look so big you’ll think you’re looking at them through a telescope. The wand on this $11 mascara is what makes this product especially unique. One side is flat to lengthen lashes up to 60% while the other side is a comb to separate lashes. It’s also ultra skinny so you can get extremely close to the lash line with ease.

Watch more L’Oreal Paris Telescopic Mascara reviews

19. Benefit Cosmetics They’re Real Beyond Mascara

“Are your eyelashes real?” will be the number one question people will ask you when you put on a few coats of Benefit Cosmetics They’re Real Beyond Mascara. To get your longest and most lifted lash ever, start by holding the brush horizontally and wiggling it through your lashes from root to tip for length and separation. Then flip the wand so you are holding it vertically and brush it up to lift the lashes.

Watch more Benefit Cosmetics They’re Real Beyond Mascara reviews

20. Maybelline Volum’ Express The Colossal Mascara

This yellow tube of Maybelline’s Volum’ Express The Colossal Mascara is giving Maybelline’s icontic pink and green tube of mascara a run for its money. This $9 mascara promises nine times more volume after just one coat thanks to its collagen infused formula and Mega Brush. This is the perfect mascara for those who only have a New York minute to apply makeup in the morning.

Watch more Maybelline The Colossal Volum’ Express Mascara reviews

Did your favorite mascara make the list? Bat your fluttery lashes, make a review, and add it below! We're always looking for a stellar mascara.